12553, New Windsor, NY
What are the best ZIP codes to buy a house around 12553?
Some of the best ZIP codes to buy a home around 12553, New York are 12550, 10950 and 12590 based on the current housing market and home values in 12553.
Is this area right for me?
A local agent can help you zero in on the area that’s perfect for you, no commitment required.
Home values in 12553
12553 is a zip code in New Windsor. There are 391 homes for sale, ranging from $39K to $11.3M.
- $425KMedian listing home price
- $239Median listing home price/Sq ft
- $338KMedian sold home price
Real estate highlights in 12553
12553 housing market
In March 2025, the median listing home price in 12553 was $425K, trending up 11.8% year-over-year. The median listing home price per square foot was $239. The median home sold price was $338K.
Sale-to-list price ratio: 100%
Homes in 12553 sold for approximately the asking price on average in March 2025.
- Buyer
- Balanced
- Seller
Top schools in 12553
12553 hosts 15 public schools rated good and higher by GreatSchools. Here are the best public schools in 12553:
Rating | School name | Grades | Reviews | |
---|---|---|---|---|
8 | Cornwall Middle School | 5 - 8 | 3 reviews | View All |
6 | New Windsor School | K - 5 | 6 reviews | View All |
5 | Vails Gate High Tech Magnet School | K - 5 | 4 reviews | View All |
5 | Little Britain Elementary School | 1 - 5 | 8 reviews | View All |
4 | Temple Hill School | K - 8 | 6 reviews | View All |
NR | Kaplan Career Academy | 4 - 12 | N/A | View All |

Amenities near 12553
- Azteca Grocery
- Hannaford Supermarkets
- Nature's Pantry
- ShopRite of Vailsgate
- ALDI
- Market Fresh
- Stop & Shop
- Price Chopper Market Center
- Walmart Supercenter
- BJ's Wholesale Club

Homes for sale in 12553
There are 391 homes for sale in 12553, but there were no new for sale listings in the last week. Additionally, there are 18 rentals, with a range of $1.6K to $3.4K per month. Discover more 12553 listings for open houses, price reduced, foreclosures, recently sold, new home communities, and new home construction.
Newest listings in 12553
Explore 12553
There are 40 ZIP Codes near 12553. 10956 has a median listing home price of $865K, making it the most expensive area. 12601 is the most affordable area, with a median listing home price of $349.5K.
Popular ZIP codes nearby 12553
All ZIP codes around 12553
ZIP Codes | Median listing home price | Listing $/SqFt | For sale | For rent | Availability |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
$379K | $248 | ||||
$545K | $288 | ||||
$429.9K | $247 | ||||
$399.9K | $238 | ||||
$853K | $370 | ||||
$424.9K | $227 | ||||
$487K | $300 | ||||
$349.5K | $237 | ||||
$549K | $247 | ||||
$699.9K | $260 | ||||
$862.3K | $394 | ||||
$865K | $392 | ||||
$644K | $319 | ||||
$397.3K | $318 | ||||
$650K | $290 | ||||
$409.9K | $246 | ||||
$619K | $279 | ||||
$579.9K | $332 | ||||
$677.9K | $276 | ||||
$499K | $249 |