Realtor.com® Real Estate App
314,000+
Garnerville, West Haverstraw real estate & homes for sale
15
Homes
Property detail for 52 Captain Shankey Dr Garnerville, NY 10923
$550,000
52 Captain Shankey Dr
Garnerville, NY 10923
Advertisement
Property detail for 102 Capt Shankey Dr Garnerville, NY 10923
$524,900
102 Capt Shankey Dr
Garnerville, NY 10923
Advertisement
Property detail for 21 Capt Shankey Dr Garnerville, NY 10923
$479,999
21 Capt Shankey Dr
Garnerville, NY 10923
Property detail for 67 Capt Shankey Dr Garnerville, NY 10923
$469,999
67 Capt Shankey Dr
Garnerville, NY 10923
Advertisement
Property detail for 138 W Railroad Ave Garnerville, NY 10923
$149,888
138 W Railroad Ave
Garnerville, NY 10923
End of matching results.
Rentals in Garnerville, West Haverstraw, NY
Find your ideal property in West Haverstraw, NY
Popular searches in West Haverstraw, NY
Open floor plan homes for sale in West Haverstraw, NYHomes for sale in West Haverstraw, NY with updated kitchenWest Haverstraw, NY homes for sale with virtual toursHomes for sale in West Haverstraw, NY with basementNew property for sale listings in West Haverstraw, NYFixer upper for sale in West Haverstraw, NYHomes for sale in West Haverstraw, NY with central airHomes for sale in West Haverstraw, NY with rental propertyHomes for sale in West Haverstraw, NY with garage 2 or moreOpen houses in West Haverstraw, NYHomes for sale in West Haverstraw, NY with modern kitchenHomes for sale in West Haverstraw, NY with garage 1 or moreSingle story homes for sale in West Haverstraw, NYHomes for sale in West Haverstraw, NY with fenced yard
Property types for sale in West Haverstraw, NY
Homes by price in West Haverstraw, NY
Homes by number of bedrooms in West Haverstraw, NY
Top real estate markets in New York
Fairport homes for saleBaldwinsville homes for saleSchenectady homes for saleAmherst homes for saleUtica homes for saleGreece homes for salePenfield homes for saleLancaster homes for saleClifton Park homes for saleAlbany homes for saleSyracuse homes for saleRochester homes for salePittsford homes for saleHamburg homes for saleWebster homes for saleBrooklyn homes for saleBuffalo homes for saleQueens homes for saleStaten Island homes for saleNew York homes for sale
Property for rent in West Haverstraw, NY
Nearby home prices
Neighborhoods near Garnerville, West Haverstraw, NY
Highland Mills Homes for Sale
$622,000
$622,000
North Elmsford Homes for Sale
$445,000
$445,000
Homecrest Homes for Sale
$475,000
$475,000
Woodstock Manor Homes for Sale
$175,000
$175,000
Nepera Park Homes for Sale
$365,000
$365,000
Central Valley Homes for Sale
$474,000
$474,000
Central Briarcliff West Homes for Sale
$1,350,000
$1,350,000
Cities near Garnerville, West Haverstraw, NY
Clarkstown Homes for Sale
$700,000
$700,000
New City Homes for Sale
$799,000
$799,000
Spring Valley Homes for Sale
$830,450
$830,450
Cortlandt Homes for Sale
$636,950
$636,950
Ossining Homes for Sale
$537,000
$537,000
Monsey Homes for Sale
$1,077,000
$1,077,000
Peekskill Homes for Sale
$400,000
$400,000
Nanuet Homes for Sale
$562,500
$562,500
Cortlandt Manor Homes for Sale
$649,950
$649,950
Nyack Homes for Sale
$669,000
$669,000
Stony Point Homes for Sale
$699,500
$699,500
Pomona Homes for Sale
$849,499
$849,499
Valley Cottage Homes for Sale
$354,950
$354,950
Mount Ivy Homes for Sale
$325,000
$325,000
Congers Homes for Sale
$729,000
$729,000
Haverstraw Homes for Sale
$425,000
$425,000
Montebello Homes for Sale
$1,600,000
$1,600,000
Wesley Hills Homes for Sale
$1,125,000
$1,125,000
Chestnut Ridge Homes for Sale
$999,000
$999,000
West Haverstraw Homes for Sale
$467,000
$467,000
Counties near Garnerville, West Haverstraw, NY
Naugatuck Valley Homes for Sale
$365,000
$365,000
New Haven Homes for Sale
$389,500
$389,500
Northwest Hills Homes for Sale
$597,000
$597,000
Mercer Homes for Sale
$445,000
$445,000
Litchfield Homes for Sale
$525,000
$525,000
Hunterdon Homes for Sale
$650,000
$650,000
Sullivan Homes for Sale
$382,499
$382,499
Morris Homes for Sale
$689,000
$689,000
Queens Homes for Sale
$635,000
$635,000
Nassau Homes for Sale
$850,000
$850,000
Rockland Homes for Sale
$775,000
$775,000
Columbia Homes for Sale
$599,000
$599,000
Monmouth Homes for Sale
$799,000
$799,000
Dutchess Homes for Sale
$499,000
$499,000
Warren Homes for Sale
$420,000
$420,000
Union Homes for Sale
$615,000
$615,000
Greene Homes for Sale
$459,000
$459,000
Kings Homes for Sale
$850,000
$850,000
New York Homes for Sale
$1,495,000
$1,495,000
Zip codes near Garnerville, West Haverstraw, NY
10901 Homes for Sale
$853,000
$853,000
10977 Homes for Sale
$862,250
$862,250
10956 Homes for Sale
$865,000
$865,000
10952 Homes for Sale
$999,450
$999,450
10562 Homes for Sale
$537,000
$537,000
10566 Homes for Sale
$397,250
$397,250
10954 Homes for Sale
$537,500
$537,500
10960 Homes for Sale
$770,000
$770,000
10567 Homes for Sale
$649,950
$649,950
10970 Homes for Sale
$749,999
$749,999
10980 Homes for Sale
$699,749
$699,749
10989 Homes for Sale
$360,000
$360,000
10965 Homes for Sale
$664,500
$664,500
10510 Homes for Sale
$1,482,500
$1,482,500
10520 Homes for Sale
$760,000
$760,000
10927 Homes for Sale
$469,000
$469,000
10920 Homes for Sale
$729,000
$729,000
10994 Homes for Sale
$859,000
$859,000
10923 Homes for Sale
$622,000
$622,000
07645 Homes for Sale
$850,000
$850,000
Facts about Garnerville, West Haverstraw, NY
Garnerville, West Haverstraw, NY housing market
Garnerville, West Haverstraw, NY rentalsMedian listing home price
$560k
Median listing home price per square foot
$339
Active listings 16
Schools in Garnerville, West Haverstraw, NY
Top rated schools
5
- Willow Grove Middle School
- View homes for sale
5
- James A Farley Elementary School
- View homes for sale
4
- Haverstraw Elementary School
- View homes for sale
Contact the school or district directly to verify enrollment eligibility.ÌýLocation provided by | Ratings provided by
GreatSchools Ratings are based on student performance on state tests, progress over time, and college readiness, in addition to how effectively schools serve students from different racial, ethnic, and socioeconomic backgrounds. Ratings are on a scale of 1 (below average) to 10 (above average). Ratings and reviews help parents compare schools. We encourage parents to also visit schools, ask questions, learn about programs, and consider family needs as part of the school selection process. Data provided by © 2025. All rights reserved.
How to buy a home in Garnerville, West Haverstraw, NY
Be prepared to buy
Get pre-approved
A pre-approval letter from a lender makes your offer stronger.
Moving cost calculator
Garnerville, West Haverstraw, NY real estate & homes for sale
Homes for sale in Garnerville, West Haverstraw, NY have a median listing home price of $574,950. There are 15 active homes for sale in Garnerville, West Haverstraw, NY, which spend an average of 59 days on the market. Some of the hottest neighborhoods near Garnerville, West Haverstraw, NY are Jefferson Valley - Yorktown, Highland Mills, North Elmsford, Homecrest, Woodstock Manor. You may also be interested in single family homes and condo/townhomes for sale in popular zip codes like 10901, 10977, or three bedroom homes for sale in neighboring cities, such as Clarkstown, New City, Spring Valley, Cortlandt, Ossining.